Jump to content

Does kink reveal who we are, or who we allow ourselves to become?


Recommended Posts

My kinks make me wonder im dominant but I love to give and I love to be touched ...
Ive got alot to learn i welcome advice

1, both. Kink can be a way to express your shadow and incorporate it into the Self. That includes spaces of the Anima/Animas as well.

2, yes. I'm a caregiver, I literally spend 40 hours a week caring for others. It's nothing like anything else in my personal life and kink is also is own seperate category of expression. Again, the shadow can be expressed in the space of kink.

3, also both, switches exist. I switch to sub when I don't want responsibility. In my work, personal life and typically kink I am the person in charge. I am good at it and it comes naturally to lead to a certain extent. When I want to be cared for the way I do others I switch.

4, I guess? People enjoy movies without wanting to enact it. Imagination is a must human nature.

5, I think shadow work is important as to why. There's a lot of psychology in sex and kink and things like CNC is often for a victim to relive parts of that experience in a way that is controlled by them. It helps to replace the memories of the act with positive memories of the cnc scene instead.

Shadow just means light isn't directly cast into it. It doesn't mean it's some dark or nefarious thing, that's a social media thingy for engagement. The best places to read are in the shadow of a tree.

Kink is whatever gets you going, sexually and that's it, basically.
I think people are trying to over-intellectualize it way too much.
And I think this urgent need to mirror public life and what one does in the bedroom is a desperate attempt to justify kink - particularly being submissive: people need to explain their turn-ons to themselves, because saying "idk, I just like *** and getting dominated" isn't enough.

There are people who are dominant in their vanilla life and dominant in the bedroom. People who are submissive people pleasers and wanna get dominated in their sexual life.

There is no "if one is dominant and carries a lot of responsibility he/she just wants to give up control for once and get slapped in the face". It's arbitrary. There is no rule, no strict pattern. People are individuals and every combination is possible.

I remember long before I even knew I was kinky when a friend of mine, who is a cop, told me he went to a dominatrix.
And after he passionately told me how hot it was for him, he instantly switched and told me something about his job and how dominant he has to be in his day to day life. It felt more like an excuse. Like "I need to get degraded and punished and get *** inflicted upon, BECAUSE my job requires me to do what a cop has to do".

Ok, you got responsibility. Alright, fine. But why then do you necessarily need to get sexually dominated, slapped around, degraded, whipped and spat on? Put in a dress and lick off boots?
Why are vanilla people who carry a lot of responsibility not feeling the urge to get consensually violated during a CNC session? Where is the "mirror rule" here?
It just doesn't apply. It's arbitrary. And that's totally fine.
Actually I think the arbitrariness makes all of this way more beautiful and makes us way more individual than all those patterns that people try to communicate as being facts.
When someone is dominant in his/her private life and this automatically means that he/she is submissive in his/her sexual (kinky) life, wouldn't that make a person see-through, boring and robbed of their individuality and of the magic of discovering someone's deeper and yet to be discovered self?

I like not knowing what a person is, likes and hides. If I got to know someone who is a cop and I'd automatically knew "ah, so you like to get dominated in the bedroom, I see", wouldn't this be boring af?
I'm as feminist as I can be, yet as a dom I like what I like. "Mirror-rule?" Maybe. But a friend of mine is pretty feminist herself and yet she likes to dominate men. No "mirror-rule". Hm. Doesn't seem to me that any "true selves" are getting revealed via kink here. No guiding thread.

Ok, I'm getting lost. What I'm trying to say is: people get off to whatever stuff. Arbitrarily. And sometimes there is no explanation other than "idk, i just like it". And that's totally fine.

Before retirement in my chosen career I was dominant, supervisory, teacher, counselor, disciplinarian, overseer, etc. My husband understood and supported my need to have the space to exercise the other aspects of my personality. When I touch the doorknob of our home it was like Dorothy opening the door and stepping into Oz. My transport was also his vehicle to our symbiotic life, one where I served as he directed. To me the term "shadow" implies a darkness or hidden quality, whereas in our reality our 'shadows' were aspects/skills we didn't/couldn't express or were not useful to experience publically.

Dominance is biblical so is staring the snake which is Jung'swhole mentality. Apollo and Dynisius are the fight between oneself. Embracing your id and understanding it are two different things. Pretending you are some dominant alpha over women when you have 0 dominance over actual men is a game of play pretend. So is thinking subservience is the lesser responsibility. Sacrifice to your woman is what subservience is the least of what it deserves.

It depends on what we are trying to accomplish within ourselves tbh I myself focus on what I can derive from the pleasure of others some of us are more driven in their own pleasure it's a 50/50 I guess all I know is that the more pleasure my partner feels the more I get out of the deal and that all that really matters.

21 hours ago, ShawnVulpes said:

1, both. Kink can be a way to express your shadow and incorporate it into the Self. That includes spaces of the Anima/Animas as well.

2, yes. I'm a caregiver, I literally spend 40 hours a week caring for others. It's nothing like anything else in my personal life and kink is also is own seperate category of expression. Again, the shadow can be expressed in the space of kink.

3, also both, switches exist. I switch to sub when I don't want responsibility. In my work, personal life and typically kink I am the person in charge. I am good at it and it comes naturally to lead to a certain extent. When I want to be cared for the way I do others I switch.

4, I guess? People enjoy movies without wanting to enact it. Imagination is a must human nature.

5, I think shadow work is important as to why. There's a lot of psychology in sex and kink and things like CNC is often for a victim to relive parts of that experience in a way that is controlled by them. It helps to replace the memories of the act with positive memories of the cnc scene instead.

Shadow just means light isn't directly cast into it. It doesn't mean it's some dark or nefarious thing, that's a social media thingy for engagement. The best places to read are in the shadow of a tree.

1. Shadows and Anima/Animus. Interesting choices. Perhaps both can be true. We are all made up of different facets, almost like presets, each resonating at a different frequency or vibration. Some remain dormant, unexplored or restrained by the expectations of everyday life. Then, occasionally, the right person, connection or dynamic brings one into focus. It reveals a curiosity or inclination that might never have found expression elsewhere.

2. Caregiving. That is an interesting distinction, especially when care is already such a significant part of everyday life. Perhaps the difference lies in the nature of the space and the relationship. One can be caring and helpful in everyday life, yet within a dynamic, the circle becomes more intimate. Words and actions take on a different quality. Gentleness, patience and attentiveness become more than qualities; they become the essentials.

3. The switch. Ah, how fortunate. There is something fascinating about the ability to transition between roles wihtout headspace glitches during switch. And yes, perhaps both explanations hold true. Everyday personality does carry into the dungeon, bringing familiar traits, instincts and tendencies. Yet the dynamic can also offer the contrast one needs. Someone accustomed to leading may occasionally wish to surrender responsibility and receive the care they so readily share. Neither expression invalidates the other.

4. Discovery and fantasy. Discovery can be far more fulfilling, even when fantasy provides the initial framing. Sometimes imagination is the invitation, while experience reveals what genuinely resonates. Though, of course, everyone enjoys a good show. Appreciating the spectacle does not mean wishing to step into it.

5. Shadow work. Agreed. Understanding the why can be just as important as understanding the desire itself. Though perhaps the distinction between exploring a fantasy and needing to resolve something through it deserves care and awareness. Not every kink needs a deeper explanation, and no single psychological interpretation fits everyone. It all comes down to understanding.

And that brings us back to the shadow itself.

There can be no shadow without light, nor light without something to cast it. Neither is inherently weak, lesser or submissive. A shadow is not the absence of worth; it is simply another consequence of how light falls.

Perhaps the most interesting parts of ourselves are not always the ones standing directly in the light.

12 hours ago, jpxiii said:

Kink is whatever gets you going, sexually and that's it, basically.
I think people are trying to over-intellectualize it way too much.
And I think this urgent need to mirror public life and what one does in the bedroom is a desperate attempt to justify kink - particularly being submissive: people need to explain their turn-ons to themselves, because saying "idk, I just like *** and getting dominated" isn't enough.

There are people who are dominant in their vanilla life and dominant in the bedroom. People who are submissive people pleasers and wanna get dominated in their sexual life.

There is no "if one is dominant and carries a lot of responsibility he/she just wants to give up control for once and get slapped in the face". It's arbitrary. There is no rule, no strict pattern. People are individuals and every combination is possible.

I remember long before I even knew I was kinky when a friend of mine, who is a cop, told me he went to a dominatrix.
And after he passionately told me how hot it was for him, he instantly switched and told me something about his job and how dominant he has to be in his day to day life. It felt more like an excuse. Like "I need to get degraded and punished and get *** inflicted upon, BECAUSE my job requires me to do what a cop has to do".

Ok, you got responsibility. Alright, fine. But why then do you necessarily need to get sexually dominated, slapped around, degraded, whipped and spat on? Put in a dress and lick off boots?
Why are vanilla people who carry a lot of responsibility not feeling the urge to get consensually violated during a CNC session? Where is the "mirror rule" here?
It just doesn't apply. It's arbitrary. And that's totally fine.
Actually I think the arbitrariness makes all of this way more beautiful and makes us way more individual than all those patterns that people try to communicate as being facts.
When someone is dominant in his/her private life and this automatically means that he/she is submissive in his/her sexual (kinky) life, wouldn't that make a person see-through, boring and robbed of their individuality and of the magic of discovering someone's deeper and yet to be discovered self?

I like not knowing what a person is, likes and hides. If I got to know someone who is a cop and I'd automatically knew "ah, so you like to get dominated in the bedroom, I see", wouldn't this be boring af?
I'm as feminist as I can be, yet as a dom I like what I like. "Mirror-rule?" Maybe. But a friend of mine is pretty feminist herself and yet she likes to dominate men. No "mirror-rule". Hm. Doesn't seem to me that any "true selves" are getting revealed via kink here. No guiding thread.

Ok, I'm getting lost. What I'm trying to say is: people get off to whatever stuff. Arbitrarily. And sometimes there is no explanation other than "idk, i just like it". And that's totally fine.

All are welcome here, and there is no need for judgement. Whether one chooses to observe, explore, experiment or simply enjoy the conversation, the freedom to do so is part of what makes a community worth having.

And agreed, there is no universal mirror rule. People are individuals, not psychological templates waiting to be decoded. Sometimes there is a deeper reason; sometimes the explanation is simply, "One likes what one likes." Neither needs defending.

As for switches, respect! There is something rather fascinating about refusing to be confined by a single label. It takes a certain confidence, and perhaps courage, to let go of expectations and allow different sides of oneself to find expression.

Perhaps that is the point of the discussion, not to prescribe patterns, but to remain curious about the possibilities. No one owes the room an explanation for what brings them pleasure, and no one should be reduced to a label before they have had the chance to reveal themselves.

After all, what is the pleasure of discovery if everything has already been assumed?

3 hours ago, odonshaw said:

It depends on what we are trying to accomplish within ourselves tbh I myself focus on what I can derive from the pleasure of others some of us are more driven in their own pleasure it's a 50/50 I guess all I know is that the more pleasure my partner feels the more I get out of the deal and that all that really matters.

That's the form of mutual understanding that explores pleasure, where others pleasure becomes part of one's own.

21 hours ago, Tulsatime1876 said:

My kinks make me wonder im dominant but I love to give and I love to be touched ...
Ive got alot to learn i welcome advice

That there lies the beautiful contradiction, that spark of curiosity, that willingness to explore, search and mutually build that safe space

4 hours ago, brisbane10824 said:

Dominance is biblical so is staring the snake which is Jung'swhole mentality. Apollo and Dynisius are the fight between oneself. Embracing your id and understanding it are two different things. Pretending you are some dominant alpha over women when you have 0 dominance over actual men is a game of play pretend. So is thinking subservience is the lesser responsibility. Sacrifice to your woman is what subservience is the least of what it deserves.

An offer and an obligation are not the same. Tribute and an offer of free use are not interchangeable, either. What is freely given does not become something owed, nor does what is granted automatically become served.

Perhaps Apollo and Dionysus offer an interesting lens: order and instinct, restraint and surrender, form and ecstasy. But embracing one does not require the rejection of the other. Nor does either dictate one's place in a dynamic.

Pleasure itself is felt, enjoyed and shared. Actions are meaningful when chosen, not presumed. Gestures may express devotion or adoration, but they lose their meaning when demanded as entitlement.

What is offered should be received with gratitude, never taken for granted.

Always asked, never assumed.

(edited)
On 11/4/2026 at 9:45 PM, staticglitch said:

There is a temptation to assume that the private self is the more authentic one, as though the public self were merely a mask.

Firstly, what a great thread! Thank you for creating it. 

As has been mentioned before, the way we navigate the coexistence of kink vs. public persona are completely individual. So I want to stress that the following is only my personal experience. 

For me, both are masks or rather strategies. Neither is more authentic than the other one, because both are a strange combination of predisposition and learned behaviours. Deep within me is pure existence, that's what could possibly be called the authentic self, everything else is added on. 

However, my quest to understand each and every one of my fantasies has helped me to deconstruct and reconstruct my brain. In this process, the former shadow part of myself has begun to turn into my preferred self-image. So much so that by now it is ever present, even in my public life. I'm beginning to find ways to be submissive at work and with friends and at the same time, I'm trying to learn how to be more in charge of what is happening in my kink life. Things are beginning to merge and it's an amazing, if confusing and highly exhausting process to go through. It seems it never was a dichotomy but two versions of myself that were waiting to complete each other. 

Edited by jinxed
3 hours ago, jinxed said:

Firstly, what a great thread! Thank you for creating it. 

As has been mentioned before, the way we navigate the coexistence of kink vs. public persona are completely individual. So I want to stress that the following is only my personal experience. 

For me, both are masks or rather strategies. Neither is more authentic than the other one, because both are a strange combination of predisposition and learned behaviours. Deep within me is pure existence, that's what could possibly be called the authentic self, everything else is added on. 

However, my quest to understand each and every one of my fantasies has helped me to deconstruct and reconstruct my brain. In this process, the former shadow part of myself has begun to turn into my preferred self-image. So much so that by now it is ever present, even in my public life. I'm beginning to find ways to be submissive at work and with friends and at the same time, I'm trying to learn how to be more in charge of what is happening in my kink life. Things are beginning to merge and it's an amazing, if confusing and highly exhausting process to go through. It seems it never was a dichotomy but two versions of myself that were waiting to complete each other. 

The purpose of exploration is always understanding, pleasure and or *** is just part of discovery. So happy exploring.

Thank you for opening this thread. The clarity of the communication absolves a lot of concern

3 hours ago, roadgem510 said:

Thank you for opening this thread. The clarity of the communication absolves a lot of concern

Always a pleasure to exchange

It allows us to be who we are- and allows for expression and safe a outlet. When done appropriately and correctly.

I think it could be either depending on the situation. For me, right now, it’s about discovering my limits and allowing myself to push those limits to find new pleasures.

1. I think it's a mix of both. It reveals who we are and let's us be a different version of ourselves.
2. Yes! Someone who is top dog out of dynamics, might either be a soft Dom or a sub, or whatever else, but everyone has different sides of themselves. I'm not the same around everyone, I am still me, though.
3. Both. I'm a sub all around lol. I am definitely not the boss of anyone (besides my child) and I definitely don't want to be in a dynamic.
4. Probably. I enjoy the fantasy of some things, but haven't tried them yet, doesn't make me like them any less.
5. Some are better left as fantasy. I have a few that I don't even tell people about because I will never do them. I will write about them, but that's it.

×
×
  • Create New...